All Time Colts Team
All Time Colts
| Position |
Player |
Span |
S |
G |
Per Game |
Per Season |
Best Season |
| QB |
Johnny Unitas |
1956-1972 |
17 |
206 |
2.49 |
30.12 |
136 |
| RB |
Lenny Moore |
1956-1967 |
11 |
136 |
4.21 |
52.00 |
98 |
| RB |
Jonathan Taylor |
2020-2025 |
6 |
75 |
5.28 |
66.00 |
112 |
| TE |
John Mackey |
1963-1971 |
9 |
126 |
1.65 |
23.11 |
54 |
| WR |
Jimmy Orr |
1962-1970 |
8 |
87 |
2.67 |
29.00 |
66 |
| WR |
Raymond Berry |
1960-1967 |
8 |
94 |
2.34 |
27.50 |
60 |
| K |
Matt Gay |
2023-2024 |
2 |
33 |
6.18 |
102.00 |
102 |
| P |
Rigoberto Sanchez |
2017-2025 |
8 |
121 |
1.39 |
21.00 |
27 |
| LS |
Luke Rhodes |
2016-2025 |
9 |
135 |
2.68 |
40.16 |
47.68 |
| OT |
Bernhard Raimann |
2022-2025 |
4 |
53 |
0.94 |
12.41 |
17.64 |
| OT |
Blake Freeland |
2023-2025 |
2 |
25 |
1.13 |
14.07 |
16.8 |
| OG |
Jim Parker |
1962-1967 |
5 |
59 |
2.44 |
28.80 |
42 |
| OG |
Quenton Nelson |
2018-2025 |
7 |
112 |
1.26 |
20.20 |
34.4 |
| C |
Ryan Kelly |
2016-2024 |
9 |
121 |
1.62 |
21.77 |
72.48 |
| DT |
DeForest Buckner |
2020-2025 |
6 |
86 |
1.97 |
28.17 |
51 |
| DT |
Grover Stewart |
2017-2025 |
9 |
132 |
0.61 |
8.89 |
22 |
| DE |
Kwity Paye |
2021-2025 |
5 |
66 |
1.41 |
18.60 |
29 |
| DE |
Dayo Odeyingbo |
2021-2024 |
4 |
61 |
1.00 |
15.25 |
34 |
| LB |
Zaire Franklin |
2018-2025 |
8 |
123 |
1.03 |
15.88 |
43 |
| LB |
E.J. Speed |
2019-2024 |
6 |
92 |
0.74 |
11.33 |
20 |
| CB |
Bobby Boyd |
1960-1968 |
9 |
121 |
2.50 |
33.56 |
48 |
| CB |
Kenny Moore |
2017-2025 |
9 |
123 |
2.82 |
38.56 |
64 |
| S |
Julian Blackmon |
2020-2024 |
5 |
66 |
1.97 |
26.00 |
46 |
| S |
Nick Cross |
2022-2025 |
4 |
58 |
1.02 |
14.75 |
31 |
| S |
Rodney McLeod |
2022 |
1 |
17 |
2.47 |
42.00 |
42 |